The Theta Chapter of Phi Beta Mu awards one Outstanding Young Bandsman award to a senior band student from a Phi Beta Mu member’s band program each year. The award honors a senior band student demonstrating strong musicianship, leadership, and scholastic success.
| Fort Mill Middle School | Leah Schwartz | 2017 |
| Hand Middle School | Julia Benitez-Nelson | 2018 |
| Florence Chapel Middle School | Jack Eitel | 2019 |
| Irmo Middle School | Sam Herring | 2020 |
| Westview Middle School | Joshua Withers | 2022 |
| Riverside Middle School | Porter Grant | 2023 |
| Batesburg-Leesville Middle School | Dontarrious Dennis | 2024 |